Hello dear
Welcome To MJ's Supper Club
MJ's Supper Club, nestled in Hortonville, WI, is a hidden gem that promises an exceptional dining experience. Known for its prime rib, tender steaks, and mouthwatering ribs, the restaurant pairs expertly prepared dishes with a fresh salad and soup bar. Patrons rave about the generous portions and flavorful potato cakes, making them a must-try. The welcoming atmosphere and attentive service enhance each visit, whether you're stopping by on a motorcycle ride or with family. With an impressive menu and a commitment to delightful customer experiences, MJ's Supper Club is set to become a cherished regular haunt for all who visit.
About
MJ's Supper Club
Welcome to MJ's Supper Club, a hidden gem nestled in the charm of Hortonville, Wisconsin. This inviting spot, located at w8326 County Rd MM, promises an unparalleled dining experience with a fine blend of rustic ambiance and gourmet cuisine.
At MJ's, the menu is a delightful testament to classic American supper club fare, featuring expertly prepared steaks that have gained rave reviews from patrons. According to Anthony Falbo, the prime rib is perfectly seasoned and served in generous portions, complemented beautifully by their renowned potato cakes—worthy of a spotlight of their own. LeAnn Ostrem Knoeck also praises the establishment for its fresh salad bar and flavorful soups, creating a well-rounded meal that doesn't break the bank.
One highlight of MJ's is the dedication to service. Guests frequently comment on the friendly and efficient staff. Heather Tiseling recounts her experience of finding MJ's after a disappointing stop elsewhere, only to be welcomed by attentive servers and a warm atmosphere. Henry McKenna echoes this sentiment, highlighting the outstanding bartending and service from their team, particularly mentioning Emma's five-star energy.
If you’re a rib aficionado, as noted by Sue Jennerjohn, MJ's is deemed the spot to savor the best ribs around, further solidifying its reputation as a must-visit for meat lovers.
Whether you're winding down after a motorcycle ride or seeking a cozy evening with friends, MJ's Supper Club offers a perfect setting imbued with good vibes and even better food. It's a space where every dish reflects culinary passion and every visit feels like coming home.
So next time you’re in the area, make your way to MJ's Supper Club—a dining experience that's not just about the food, but about the joy of good company and great service.
For reservations or inquiries, you can reach them at +1 920-779-9701.
Book a table
Make A Reservation
“ We had an excellent meal Saturday night. The salad bar was fresh and the soup was delicious. The steaks (prime rib and tenderloin) were all made to perfection. Great value for the price. Great service. We’ll be back! ”
“ If you want the best ribs around this is your spot! Everything you need on the salad bar too. Always service with a smile. ”
“ I can’t believe I have never to MJ’s before, yes it is off the beaten path, but it has to be right up with the best meal at supper club I have ever had. My wife and I try to get to a supper club weekly and we have a pretty solid rotation that we hit, and we will differentially be adding this to our regular rotation. And it’s only a minute drive! Prime rib was amazing, well seasoned and much bigger cut than I was anticipating, and the potato cakes should be a meal all on their own! ”
“ The bartender was excellent friendly and well-placed they don't get much better than her so wait staff was excellent which was Emma I would give her five stars energy and the food was extremely well-prepared I highly recommend stopping and having dinner there ”
“ My husband and I came across MJs on a Saturday afternoon motorcycle ride. Initially we had stopped at a place in Hortonville for dinner, but the service was terrible and we never had our order taken so we left. In search of a place for dinner, we arrived at MJs. The backyard bar was pretty busy, but inside was not. We had a couple drinks at the bar where the bartender was very friendly. Our waitress (I believe her name was Shay) was awesome! She was super sweet and very attentive to our table. I had the Coconut Shrimp with the potato cakes and my husband ordered a 12 oz steak. The soup/salad bar had a lot of options and was very fresh. I thought the prices were reasonable, food was great and service was amazing! We will DEFINITELY be back :) ”
“ Third time dining, took a risk and had the perch dinner. Very good, light batter, great salad bar. Hot bacon dressing!! Friendly bartenders. Waitstaff great. ”
“ We were led to this place because of a 3hr wait at the “other” supper club down the road...I can 100% confirm that this place is equal if not better! We walked in and waited no more than 15 mins before being seated on a SATURDAY!!! The prime rib is amazing! Flavorful and adding a lobster tail was the cherry on top! We will be back! Amazing staff!!! ”
“ Fine dining experience, everything delicious nice soup and salad bar, seafood platter has everything you need and more, the tenderloin and shrimp combo was very good and comes with au gus really good, the service was excellent! Short staff but she kept up with every table, very proud of her efforts! Check out this place pretty sure you will add this to your dining list ”